The city of Phoenix has floated the idea of closing hiking trails whenever temperatures reach 110 degrees or higher. Given that the Coachella Valley regularly hits temperatures that are, scientifically speaking, hotter than balls, it raises a fair question.

Should we be doing the same thing here?

According to AZ Central, the Phoenix Parks and Recreation Board considered a rule that would close trails to hikers when temperatures exceed 110 degrees and ban dogs once temps hit 100.

Opponents argue that the rule would be difficult to enforce. Supporters argue something far simpler: it could save lives.

In just one weekend, six hikers died in Arizona due to extreme heat. That’s not a hypothetical risk. That’s a body count.

Like Arizona, the Coachella Valley does not charge hikers for being rescued. Those rescues, however, are very much not free. Helicopters, first responders, and medical care all cost money, and that money comes from everyone.

In theory, a rule like this shouldn’t be necessary. Common sense should be enough to tell people that hiking in 120+ degree heat is a bad idea.

Unfortunately, common sense has a poor track record in the summer.

Maybe full trail closures are extreme. Maybe they aren’t. At the very least, it seems reasonable to ask whether we should do more than simply hope people make smart decisions.

Even something as basic as large, unmissable heat warning signs might prevent a few avoidable rescues. Or worse.

The desert isn’t dangerous because it’s unfair. It’s dangerous because it doesn’t care.

If you’re heading out on the trails in extreme heat, please don’t. And if you do anyway, bring far more water than you think you need and understand the risks you’re taking.